Sexual Abuse in the Catholic Church: Former Bishop Speaks Out

6 Comments
Join the Conversation
Bishop Geoffrey Robinson - Ingrid Shafer
Bishop Geoffrey Robinson - Ingrid Shafer
In Australia this week, a former Catholic bishop who spent years defending victims of child sexual abuse reveals that he too, is a victim of sexual abuse.

On April 28, 2010, The Australian Women’s Weekly Magazine reported that former Catholic Bishop Geoffrey Robinson, when he was a child, was sexually abused by a stranger. To this day, at age 72, Bishop Robinson is filled with terror when a person approaches him from behind. In The Weekly Magazine interview, the retired Bishop stated, “Sixty years disappear in a split second. In that sense, the memory never goes away.”

Sexually Abused by a Stranger

When Bishop Robinson was in his early teen years he was sexually attacked by a stranger. He says, “I’m still quite confused about it,” and he is aware that his case is rare because most children are abused by a relative or trusted individual. He says a middle-aged man came at him from behind and grabbed him on the shoulders before he was assaulted, not a paedophile priest. Bishop Geoffrey Robinson did with the memory what too many victims do, “I put it in the attic of my mind.”

Speaking Out Against the Vatican

Many years ago Bishop Robinson was appointed to lead the Catholic Church’s response to sexual abuse allegations by priests and paedophile priests. His experiences while fulfilling this position left him disillusioned.

In his interview with The Weekly he spoke out about his doubt over some of the Catholic Church’s teachings and his internal struggle. He said that his belief in God became strengthened as his faith in the church as an institution was diminishing. It was a journey that gave him the courage after so many decades, to speak out against the Vatican.

In 2007, Columba Press published Bishop Robinson’s book Confronting Power and Sex in the Catholic Church: Reclaiming the Spirit of Jesus. His book sent shockwaves throughout the church. He calls on the Vatican to rethink centuries-old beliefs on women, sexuality and marriage. One of Bishop Robinson’s arguments is that obligatory celibacy is one of the reasons why child sexual abuse has become a crisis within the Catholic Church.

Shortly after the book was published, he was removed as bishop and reprimanded by Rome. Bishop Robinson has no regrets because “I want to change things.”

Mostly Boys Are Sexually Abused by Priests

The former Bishop of Sydney says that boys are suffering more than girls at the hands of priests who sexually abuse. This is partly due to a larger number of boys who interact more with priests than girls.

On April 15, 2010, a Newsweek Magazine story reports that according to researchers at John Jay College of Criminal Justice, between 1950 and 2002 there were 246 girls (under eight years of age) who were sexually abused by priests (which represent 14% of all female victims). The same research indicates that 236 boys under eight years of age were sexually assaulted by priests which represent only 3% of all male victims.

Bishop Robinson is Respected

In his years as Sydney’s auxiliary bishop, Bishop Robinson’s devotion to victims was highly respected by numerous people. His supporters acknowledge his courage to speak out and they admire his integrity.

Bishop Robinson believes had women been given greater importance and a larger voice in the Catholic Church, they would not be experiencing the epidemic of child sexual abuse in the church. The former bishop also believes that until the church holds a conference including all bishops to revise the old doctrine, this issue will not be resolved.

Additional Reading:

Church Sex Scandals Are not just a Catholic Crisis

Sources:

The Australian Women’s Weekly, Celibacy, abuse and keeping the faith (accessed April 29, 2010)

Newsweek Magazine, What about the Girls? (accessed April 29, 2010)

Karen Stephenson, Nyssa Woudstra

Karen Stephenson - Karen has written for several newspapers and print media in addition to many online publications. She holds a B.A. in English and an ...

rss
Advertisement
Leave a comment

NOTE: Because you are not a Suite101 member, your comment will be moderated before it is viewable.
Submit
What is 1+6?

Comments

Apr 30, 2010 11:39 AM
Guest :
With all due respect to the former Bishop, his suppositions could not be more wrong. A man (a priest in this case) who is a pedophile is sexually attracted to children. How is it then that more exposure to women in the church or even allowing priests to marry would suddenly take away a pedophile's desire for sex with children? The idea is ridiculous.
Apr 30, 2010 8:59 PM
Guest :
Seriously, this guy is just a massive egotist. He's a heretic with an axe to grind - and as such, he's given all the media attention he could possibly want.

What the Church actually teaches about this stuff is really on the mark. To claim there is an issue with what the Church actually teaches on the matter of sexuality is either born of ignorance (not true of him - probably you, though) or, more likely, odium fidei - hatred of the Faith.

Really - it's' people like him who were the problem, making what are the unimpeachable teachings of the Church unclear with muddled thought - and more to the point, muddled public speech.

This guy who is on record as saying that pedophile priests didn't think what they were doing was a sin: either he's right and his ridiculous statement proves my point, or he's an idiot and part of the problem.

Seriously - as early as the 4th Century AD, Christian texts - like the Didache - reminded us "thou shalt not corrupt boys". Everybody in the Church who has read that had pretty much known what it meant all this time: pedophilia is neither new to the world, nor to the Church. Hell - the Nazis did a pedophilia scare of the same sort we see today in Germany in the '30s. Not that there wasn't some underlying cause then as now - but it's the "Big Lie" thing - statistically, the coverage you are seeing is so vastly overinflated, it can only be construed as a "Big Lie".

Anyway, ignorance of history combined with, I'll charitably call it "confusion" about the reasons behind moral prohibitions, lead to the _real_ things behind the scandal which has been pumped up.

However, the _incredible_ disingenuity of the left on this subject is mind-numbing. What pisses me off is that the majority - seriously big numbers- of this stuff happened in radically liberal dioceses. It's the liberal pseudoCatholics who got us into this mess, and the liberal establishment who is flogging the Church over it out of all proportion.

I point to the Didache again: "For in the last days {the false prophets} and corrupters shall be multiplied, and the sheep shall be turned into wolves, and love shall be turned into hate. For as lawlessness increaseth, {they shall hate one another and shall persecute and betray.
May 1, 2010 9:24 PM
Guest :
Thank god for former bishop geoffrey robinson .. the vatican has been covering up abuse claims for decades and if it is proved that the pope covered up crimes in the USA and Munich then he must abdicate and all the priests who committed crimes against children and god should face the full rigours of the law .. show them the same level of mercy that they showed the survivors , here's a question , why isn't there the same level of abuse in the protestant church ?? They have female vicars, they are allowed to marry ,,"they lead "normal"lives ...And if the rest of you are true christians , you'll show solidarity to the survivors of abuse .. thanks
May 1, 2010 10:39 PM
protest2020 :
Please focus on the outdated , dangerous and un-natural vow of celibacy which has been the route cause of clerical paedophilia over the centuries (the protestant church doesn't have a major problem) add to that the fact that the abuse was swept under the carpet and there was an unwillingness of governments and judiciary to intervene .. The Catholic church has conducted its business under a veil of secrecy and denial for far too long , they were a law unto themselves .. Now that a few brave survivors have come foreward such as Christine Buckley and Michael O'brien the church it seems is running scared .. In Ireland the abuse scandal has been called Irelands holocaust as thousands of children were abused and now more and more survivors are coming foreward , the ripple effect is now global with survivors coming foreward from Brazil , Munich , Malta , too many countries to name .. Also , if it is proved that the Pope covered up abuse as is alleged then he will have no option but to abdicate ..The Catholic church as it stands at the moment is still clinging to the past .. Three things that need urgent attention and consideration .. celibacy .. get rid of it , re-humanize the church ..Accountability ,, the notion that the church is a law unto itself has to end , The role of woman in the church needs a complete overhaul ... The church needs to be dragged kicking and screaming into the 21st century ... Public opinion is changing , they like myself are demanding that that named priests involved in the recent scandal should suffer the full rigours of the law and i call on true christians to show solidarity to the survivors ... I can only imagine what it would be like to be raped..
May 5, 2010 4:52 PM
Guest :
Today it is fashionable to fall from grace --like a child actor who grows up or a politician who looses his or her seat --then to write a book claiming to have been sexually abused ---then to go on Oprah. Come on...enough of this malarkey.
Sep 1, 2011 12:04 PM
Guest :
This problem goes back centuries and is long overdo for exposure. Bishop Robinson should be given accolades for his courage. We need more people like him in the church and not cover-ups. How deplorable...God is watching!
6 Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement