Ghan-Buri-Ghan, Where Are You?: Re: Re: PJ RoTK etc

» elendil112 - Re: Re: PJ RoTK etc

In response to message posted by StoneDragon:

there are really many scenes missing and no accurate. for example, Theoden at the battle of Helm's Deep should have 1000 men of his own, and 1000 men under Gamling the Old. also no ELVES aided them. Only Erkenbrand, Gandalf and 1000 men helped Theoden. The Battle of Pelennor fields had three errors. Firstly, Theoden could have led 10000 riders and wiped out the enemy host but chose to leave 4000 men for defence. In the movie he and Eomer and the other UNKNOWN marshal of the mark(which should be Elfhelm) led just some 3000-4000 riders. Secondly there should be quite a number of Gondorian Knights and Swan-Knights of Dol-Amroth issuing from the gate, not just defend the gate. I estimated the number to be some 3000.
Also, Aragorn and co. did not lead the Army of the Dead and assault the host of Minas Morgul. He instead led the Army of the Dead and some 2000 men
who came from a city and captured the fleet of Pelagir.
Lastly, the battle at the Morannon proved also to be very wrong. There should be at least 5000 men to attack some 50,000 orcs and allies of Mordor. And when Sauron had passed away from Middle-Earth, the Orcs and spell-enslaved beasts should either slay themselves, or hide in holes. Only the remmants of the Easterlings and Haradrim fought the Host of the West.
They actually also the not show the assault on Dol-Gurdur by the host of Lorien led by Celeborn and Galadriel, and the battle fought by the Dwarves, Orcs and some men.

-- posted by elendil112