Suite101

Mein Kampff: Hitler's Master Plan - Part 1

Read the article this discussion is about


  1. rkewin
  2. Abhishek_c
  3. rkewin

This archived discussion is "read only".
For the corresponding "live" discussions, post in the active topic forum here.



Top 1.   Mar 15, 2001 9:39 AM

» rkewin - Mr. Waller's nonsense...

Apparently Mr. Waller has read "Mein Kampf" and gives us a thumbnail sketch type of book review. Of course he concludes that Hitler was mad, evil, pulled things out of the air, and wandered around topics.

As I have stated before, Mr. Waller refuses (for whatever 'mad' reason) to see things from the other side - the German side.

Germans love detailed analysis and discussions. Hitler's style of writing reflects this - even I would have shortened some of the points he was making - to keep them simpler and easier to communicate.

If Hitler was mad and evil because he saw Jews as enemies of the German nation, then tens of millions of other Germans were mad and evil also since they agreed with him. And most of these millions had these views long before Hitler came along.

Mr. Waller has not done his homework, or is repeating conclusions by other so-called historians. He states that Hitler just made up some parts of his arguments. I doubt that any critical investigation into Hitler's thoughts and actions by most unbiased observers would conclude that he was anything but convinced, informed and careful about every part of his message.

I especially am amused and concerned that Mr. Waller and other so-called moral people still think that the Allies were mostly good and the Nazis mostly bad. I have stated in other responses to Mr. Waller's writings that the facts do not support this conclusion.

Finally, in his maladjusted morality Mr. Waller says that Hitler's view on the Jews in Mein Kampf are mad, evil, bad.

Well, guess what world, look at what has happened since WW 2 - racial mixing has produced the destruction of morality, culture, traditions, culture, education, and the economy. Jews have gladly championed this mixing (but have strangely not done much of it themselves!).

Jewish style economics has us in forever in debt, and a significant percentage of the government and industry are now owned by Jews, who all agree on the message of 'all is well'.

I am stating facts, Mr. Waller. Isn't it time you did too?

-- posted by rkewin



Top 2.   Apr 2, 2001 7:38 AM

» Abhishek_c - Re: Mr. Waller's nonsense...

In response to message posted by rkewin:

The twain shall never meet - is a saying IO am reminded of when I read your letter here again.

Sir, lets play the game according to your rules now, lets play by facts.


HISTORY is a fact, it has happened and it has been PROVED that it did.

World War 2 and Hitler's role in it are FACTS.

Mein Kampf is again a fact, but the contents therein? -

With all due respect to you, I was absolutely taken aback when you said JEWISH ECONOMY. Is there anything like that? Can any financial transaction be dictated by a religion ? Is it a FACT? I know of many instances of North American policies, (government) in which no Jew was involved, which went haywire. So can we say that AMERICAN ECONOMICS is dangerous for the rest of the world? Will it be a fact? Dangerous economic ramifications CAN be a fact , but Dangerous NORTH AMERICAN economic ramifications cannot be a fact.

Certainly not. No matter what, you cannot attribute charecteristics to people on basis of their religion.
Its not the origin, its the content. Hitler's book is not being judged by its origin, which happens to Hitler, but by its content.
As for the "Moral" historians, of which you claim Mr.Waller to be one, try and see the bigger picture.

The word history if broken up means Hi-Story. And every story has a moral in the end. Mr. Waller is just telling us what he experienced, and for his biases, isnt he allowed to have them? Just as you have yours, and I have mine.

And History is and should be BIASED. It is the only way we can decipher good or bad. It is a yardstick for us, in the future, to prevent a great catastrophe, one like Hitler brought about.

And as you must have noticed my bias in the previous sentence.....its because I have read history, understood the moral and learnt my lesson.

You sir, have done the same. Although from a different perspective, but you have used history as a yardstick, and by this you have presented your feelings to us.

For every argument you might have for justifying Hitler, someone else will be ready with two to deny it.

But in the end, no solution is reached.

The mass media has definitely played a role in Hitler's villanious figure, but this time they were close to the truth. A friend of mine, here in Canada, is German. His family still lives in Germany. His dad was part of the Hitler youth, and then was in the army before desserting.

According to him it was not cowardice, but something called human feelings. His father was once stationed to patrol the Jew ghettos, and the atrocities he witnesses in his one month of duty there, was enough to make him sick.

These are FACTS. Hard core facts.

Please do think of those starved jewish kids, who were brutally beaten when trying to steal a loaf of bread - their crime : HUnger. FACTS again , sir.

The truth they say is bitter, and maybe thats why most people find it hard to swallow. Hence I dont blame you.

-- posted by Abhishek_c



Top 3.   Jun 20, 2001 12:14 PM

» rkewin - Mr. A's facts

Mr. A, you are confused- Jews are a race, not a religion. This race has since the beginning of time gotten involved heavily in every government and economy by becoming middlemen and advisors. Their style includes overcharging, overtaxing, high interest rates, little real work done by them, paying off the government to make laws that help them and hurt others - very obvious that this continues to today. Just so it's not subtle, yes there are non-Jews who do the same thing but Jews control much more of our media and economy, and have brought out the natural greed of non-Jews and made it patriotic to have an out-of-control capitalistic economy. You still confuse feelings and facts and are playing the numbers game again. Yes, you can find more people who would disagree than agree with me, but numbers don't make it right. Morality is very subjective, while facts and virtues are not. So, don't apply emotions to history. As for the HJ dude who couldn't stomach the atrocities, there are many patriotic duties that not all can handle. Would you have guts to kill the red-man if you were drafted into the U.S. Army a hundred years ago? If not, well - that job would be given to someone else, and it was a job that the majority of U.S. citizens wanted done. Same case with Germany in WW2 - these are facts - deal with it aside from your feelings.

-- posted by rkewin



Please follow the guidelines set forth in the Suite101 Posting Etiquette when adding to the discussion.