Elitism in Astronomy

Posted by Kelly Whitt Oct 11, 2007

There's something about astronomy that has always bothered me. Isn't there room for everyone? It seems that hobbyists, no matter the hobby, like to get others involved and excited about the subject matter. Astronomers do this too, with sidewalk astronomy, alerting co-workers about an upcoming meteor shower, or sharing a web article with someone who might be interested.

But at the same time, there seems to be a feeling among astronomers that they are "above" those who don't know as much about astronomy. They need to remember there was a time when they didn't know much either, even if that time was when they were 10 years old. We all have to start somewhere. Why do some feel a need to deride others for purchasing a go-to telescope or for the magazine they read? How has separatism and elitism ever been good for any organization or group? If you simply feel the need to pat yourself on the back because you are so great that you can star-hop without a sky chart or a go-to telescope and that you read one magazine over another or even eschew them all together for refereed journals, well good for you. In the meantime, your self-righteous behavior may be giving some people the belief that everyone in astronomy is an arrogant prick. I'm here to tell you we're not.

Just as within any group, astrophiles have their winners and losers. If you are new to the hobby, don't be put off by the losers. Let your passion be your passport. You are welcome here.