A Question of Copyright '02
A number of articles about the case appear in the Financial
Times' site. A lead article by Lawrence Lessig appears there,
with responses from Thomas Hazlett, Richard Epstein, Edward
Welbourne and Frank Walker (the responses appear
on the page below Lessig's article).
[T]he striking feature of the argument was that in spite
of 600 pages of filings in support of the Sonny Bono law, it
was clear that the justices did not believe the extension had
anything to do with the constitutional aim of promoting progress.
Rather, they expressed an impatient contempt for what Congress
had done. The question they were struggling with (rightly) was
whether they had the power to do anything about it.
An article in the LA Times
also gives an excellent overview, with details on both sides of
the issue. (Requires registration.)
Lessig doesn't merely want to free the past. He wants to
free the future as well. That's something else that the entertainment
companies want to lock up. The laws they are proposing and the
technologies they are developing, he says, will make creativity
on the Internet a wholly owned subsidiary of the Recording Industry
Assn. of America and the Motion Picture Assn. of America.
A series of four articles by Dan Kohn, published in TidBITs
(a free email and Web publication covering the Macintosh Internet
community), offers a unique analysis of the situation and goes
a long way towards suggesting alternatives to the current copyright
compensation models.
Put simply, in a world where there are essentially no costs
to replicate content and it is effectively impossible to stop
anyone from doing so at will, the current economic model underpinning
content creation will be dead.
An interesting follow-up, and one that ties in more directly
and references Lessig's Supreme court case, is an article by TidBITs
publisher, Adam C. Engst, which stems, he says, from an attempt
to explain to his three-year old the need to share toys .
It may be nearly impossible to create something new without
reference or influence from a work of the past.
From these the links expand exponentially, spirally ever outward.
See the above articles for an seemingly endless supply of links
to additional news, commentary, call and responses. Here are a
few examples:
- Read the TidBITs Talk postings in response to the above articles
(see bottom of the article pages).
The copyright of the article
A Question of Copyright '02
in
Theatre is owned by Steven M. Alper. Permission to republish
A Question of Copyright '02
in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.
Go To Page:
1
2
3
Articles in this Topic
Discussions in this Topic