Home » Politics & Society » Political Economy » U.S. Not Getting Its Money's Worth

U.S. Not Getting Its Money's Worth

© Bryan Johnson

In the battle over whether to cut funding for America's foreign-aid program -- and its main dispenser of funds, the Agency for International Development (AID) -- the Clinton administration always insists cuts would be a mistake. Foreign aid, the White House claims, helps the United States gain influence with countries around the world and builds to gaining international support for U.S. foreign policy. But if that's true, why do most countries receiving U.S. foreign aid vote against the United States most of the time?

During the 1996 session of the United Nations, 68 percent of countries that receive foreign aid voted against the United State a majority of the time. The United States' top 10 foreign-aid recipients will receive more than $6 billion from the United States this year. Despite this support, six of them cast their U.N. ballots against the United States in more than half of the votes last year.

For example, India, the sixth largest recipient of U.S. aid, will receive more than $154 million in 1997. Yet, last year it voted against the United States 76 percent of the time. Egypt, the second-largest recipient of U.S. foreign aid at nearly $2.1 billion, cast its U.N. ballot against the United States 61 percent of the time. Other examples of just how little respect U.S. foreign aid earns from other nations:

* Laos, which was cut off from U.S. aid in 1992 for human-rights abuses, will receive nearly $2.5 million in U.S. foreign aid this year. Yet, in 1996 it cast U.N. votes against the United States 74 percent of the time -- more than even Libya.

* Bangladesh, which received $70 million in U.S. foreign aid in 1996, voted against the United States 65 percent of the time.

* The Philippines, despite remarkable progress in economic reform, will still receive $65 million in U.S. foreign aid this year. Yet, in 1996 it voted against the United States 61 percent of the time.

* Mexico, whose economy was bailed out by President Clinton to the tune of $40 billion in 1994, will receive nearly $26 million in U.S. foreign aid this year. Yet, last year Mexico sided against the United States in the United Nations 61 percent of the time.

* Colombia, twice decertified by the Clifton administration for not cooperating with the United States in the fight against international drug trafficking, voted against the United States 61 percent of the time. Still, the Clifton administration requested $2 million in U.S. aid for Colombia in fiscal year 1997.

* Ethiopia, receiving $106 million in U.S. foreign aid this year, stood against the United

The copyright of the article U.S. Not Getting Its Money's Worth in Political Economy is owned by . Permission to republish U.S. Not Getting Its Money's Worth in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.