Ally McBeal's Lesbian Kiss, Competition, and Government Censors


© Bryan Johnson

In the November 9, 1998 episode of the popular Fox series Ally McBeal, actress Jane Krakowsi (Elaine in the show) passionately kisses actress Calista Flockhart ( Ally in the show) for what seemed like minutes. What Ellen DeGeneres' prime time kiss lacked in passion and sexiness, and even appeal for that matter, the Flockhart/Krakowski kiss made up for by a factor of ten. What makes this scene truly memorable in network TV history was not necessarily the kiss itself, it is that it went almost completely unnoticed by the media (which usually can't resist trumping up stories on whenever the networks air controversial subject matter).

It seems like just last week, (actually it was just last week) that McBeal, one of Fox's top rated shows, was being criticized by the Catholic Church for its trivial treatment of confession. This, it turns out, received much press. So far, nothing on the kiss. Maybe this is a sign that network TV is maturing and that those in the media like what they see. Indeed, Seinfeld's masturbation episode, along with its oral sex episode significantly pushed the boundaries of what kind of subject matter networks were willing to address on TV. Both of those episodes (and too many other Seinfeld episodes to count) received much press. But Ally's tongue dancing with another women has been largely ignored.

To digress just minute, I believe that it is the upstart Fox Network that really deserves the credit for pushing the boundaries on Network TV adult content, not Seinfeld. Anyone remember Handicap Man on In Living Color? Or Homie the Clown? How about Al Bundy's favorite magazine "Biguns"? Or the old hand down the pants in front of the TV tube? When Fox burst onto the scene in the late 1980s, it not only provided competition to the Big Three networks ( ABC, CBS, and NBC), but it began to challenge the very essence of network broadcasts.

Anyway, while it is a welcome sign that network TV is addressing many taboo issues it once would have never even considered, it is also disturbing to see other performers who are continually singled out by the U.S. government for persecution. Take the nationally syndicated radio talk show host Howard Stern. Not only did the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) fine Stern for using the word penis (a word used regularly on talk radio), but when his radio show does appear on the cable channel extra, the E! Network, the FCC requires that any scenes with kissing lesbians must be censored. How can a network, prime time broadcast of two women kissing on Ally McBeal get away with that while the E! Network (which few people even get on their cable providers) is forced to censor a lesbian kiss? This sounds like a double standard to me.

Go To Page: 1 2


The copyright of the article Ally McBeal's Lesbian Kiss, Competition, and Government Censors in Political Economy is owned by . Permission to republish Ally McBeal's Lesbian Kiss, Competition, and Government Censors in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.

Post this Article to facebook Add this Article to del.icio.us! Digg this Article furl this Article Add this Article to Reddit Add this Article to Technorati Add this Article to Newsvine Add this Article to Windows Live Add this Article to Yahoo Add this Article to StumbleUpon Add this Article to BlinkLists Add this Article to Spurl Add this Article to Google Add this Article to Ask Add this Article to Squidoo


Here's the follow-up discussion on this article: View all related messages

2.   Nov 20, 1998 8:08 AM
Thanks Rick:

Thanks for the post. Although I must admit that I am perplexed by it. I am not sure exactly to what it is you are questioning. If you are questioning my characterization of Ally's kiss ...


-- posted by BJohnson


1.   Nov 19, 1998 4:57 PM
Brian,

I don't know if I am too old or that you are too naive. I read your column weekly, you have a lot to say, and a lot to learn from. And I am grateful. I do think, however, life has a lot to ...

-- posted by RickR





For a complete listing of article comments, questions, and other discussions related to Bryan Johnson's Political Economy topic, please visit the Discussions page.