The (No) Diaper Decision


© Sara McGrath

Before my daughter was born, I planned to use cloth diapers. I didn't do much research on the differences between cloth and disposables. Cloth just seemed like the "natural" choice. It didn't occur to me then that cloth and disposables weren't the only options, so I bought a dozen prefold diapers, pins, and some plastic pants from the department store. But, before I even gave cloth a chance, I changed my mind.

I had read arguments from both sides on two common concerns. Diaper rash was just as likely in plastic pants over cloth as in disposables, and frequent loads of laundry impacted the environment as did frequent trash bags of used disposables. I felt as if there was no good choice, so I opted for the "easy" one--disposables.

It was eight months before I happened across a link to an elimination communication (also known as natural infant hygiene) website. How could I not have considered the most natural option of all? No diapers. No diaper rash.

My eight-month-old daughter was well past the six-month window of opportunity for easier learning, but my conscience would no longer accept any other method of meeting her elimination needs. Here's what we did.

First, I had to learn my daughter's elimination patterns and signals. I quickly noticed that she always peed after waking in the morning, after naps, and not long after nursing. She always paused to pee or poop, and she appeared to focus her attention inward.

Next, I had to decide what she would wear, and where I would take her to eliminate. At first, I put diapers on her as a backup for when I didn't recognize her cues in time. This works for some parents, but for us the diaper acted as a barrier to our communication. It wasn't until I decided to do elimination communication (EC) "all the way," (bare-bottomed) that my daughter's signals became obvious to me. Those puddles on the floor motivated me to really tune in.

In the beginning, I hurried my daughter to the big toilet, but I decided that we needed a little potty in the main room for close calls. The Baby Bjorn Little Potty was just the right size for her to squat on (http://babybjorn.com).

Another choice I faced was whether to also practice EC while we were away from home and at night. I found that the trick to practicing EC with my daughter when we were out was finding a place where she was comfortable using the toilet. Usually she would hold it. I brought extra pants along, as I had once brought extra diapers, just in case. Nightime EC was simple. My daughter held it until morning almost every night. She didn't want to wake up in a puddle any more than I did. I kept the potty next to the bed for her wake up pee. I sewed several of her baby blankets together as an absorbant pad for her to sleep on, just in case.

Go To Page: 1 2


The copyright of the article The (No) Diaper Decision in Natural Parenting is owned by . Permission to republish The (No) Diaper Decision in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.

Post this Article to facebook Add this Article to del.icio.us! Digg this Article furl this Article Add this Article to Reddit Add this Article to Technorati Add this Article to Newsvine Add this Article to Windows Live Add this Article to Yahoo Add this Article to StumbleUpon Add this Article to BlinkLists Add this Article to Spurl Add this Article to Google Add this Article to Ask Add this Article to Squidoo


Here's the follow-up discussion on this article: View all related messages

4.   May 17, 2004 11:14 PM
In response to message posted by ErinKinloch:

There are many aspects of Elimination Communication (Infant Potty Training) tha ...


-- posted by msaraann


3.   May 17, 2004 11:34 AM
When I first had my son his great Nana took us to the drug store right away to buy this cream. My poor son seemed to get rashes from the wipes and certain scents added to diapers, I agree this is a wo ...

-- posted by ErinKinloch


2.   Apr 28, 2004 4:52 AM
My son is 40 years old. Whether there was such a thing as disposable diapers at the time or not, I don't remember, but we certainly never used one. He also never had a diaper rash. Inside the flane ...

-- posted by biogardener


1.   Aug 2, 2003 1:47 AM
A helpful article on the advantages and disadvantages of cloth, disposable, and no diapers, Sara.

Parents or soon-to-be parents of infants interested in knowing more about the third option, no diap ...


-- posted by rahunter_nf





For a complete listing of article comments, questions, and other discussions related to Sara McGrath's Natural Parenting topic, please visit the Discussions page.