Brown returns as Rollie Tyler, the special-effects whiz who has turned his back on all of that. Now he's a toymaker, with a girlfriend, Kim (Rachel Ticotin), and her son Chris (Dominic Zamprogna) to take care of. Chris' father and Kim's ex-husband Mike (Tom Mason) is a cop, and things are pretty cordial between them all. So much so that Mike asks Rollie to come out of retirement to help him with a case. Rollie is hesitant at first, but eventually agrees. In the process, however, Mike is killed, and Rollie begins to think cops might be involved, again. So when he's being pursued by bad guys and hanging from a fire escape, he's immensely relieved to see Leo McCarthy (Dennehy) coming to the rescue. Leo and Rollie, if you remember from the first one, took money a mobster had hidden in a Swiss bank account at the end, so while Rollie's a toymaker, Leo opened a bar. But he somehow still has contacts with the police department, so he agrees to help out.
As with many sequels, there are a lot of similarities to the plot of the first one, primarily that Leo doesn't appear until halfway through. As he did in the first one, he gives this one a jolt, and brings some much-needed character development (it's nice, for example, to see him back with police computer whiz Velez (Jossie DeGuzman)). And the best parts of the movie have him dealing with Liz Kennedy (Joanna Gleason), the D.A. and ex-girlfriend of Leo's who knows a lot more than she's telling. They have good chemistry, and give off the feeling of two old pros who are going to do their jobs no matter what's surrounding them.