Double Standards


© lawhawk

Are we holding Israel to a double standard when it comes to the treatment of others? I know that this article will definetely wrankle some people out there that think that Israel has definetely not been good at treating Palestinians at best. However, if we look at the historical treatment of the Palestinians during the period of 1948-1997 and compare their treatment to the treatment of other groups in the region by national leaders we find that there really isn't much of a difference, except in terms of public outcry in Western media and there is definetely something wrong with that.

Israel cracked down on Palestinian communities and individuals when terrorist attacks occurred, injuring Israeli citizens. Confiscation of lands and territory occurred, but generally with rule of law applying. There were instances where the Israeli security forces mistreated Palestinian detainees, including torture and death under mysterious circumstances while in custody. While these incidents are important and should not be made light of, the actions are well within the norm of other countries, especially within the region.

During the 1980s, Syrian President Hafez al-Assad basically eliminated his opposition by wiping out an entire city. This city, Hama, was home to the Muslim Brotherhood, a group that sought to limit the Westernization of Islamic culture and maintain traditional values. The Brotherhood became increasingly vocal during the 1980s and it came to a head when Assad called on the military to capture several leaders living in Hama. Word spread quickly and soon armed insurrection began with the Brotherhood fighting off the Syrian intelligence troops sent in initially. As the fighting intensified, Assad called in the regular military and systematically pulverized the town into non-existence. He wiped out his entire opposition in one fell swoop killing an estimated 25,000-50,000 in the process and detaining and imprisoning thousands more. Syria doesn't like this incident coming to light and many compare it to the American Civil War.

Assad played by the rules of the region which basically state that an individual who rules a country does so completely and without any compunction to use violence to achieve total control over their domain. This lesson is also seen in the actions of Saddam Hussein in his treatment of the Kurds in Northern Iraq during the 1980s and following the Gulf War.

Saddam Hussein has been after the Kurds for a long time since they oppose his regime and have sought to create an independent country in Northern Iraq, plus seem to have the backing of Iraq's rival Iran. To Hussein, this was completely unacceptable, given that his government controlled all of Iraq and to give up any part would be a sign of weakness to external enemies; especially Iran. Therefore, Hussein ordered the campaign to eliminate all Kurdish resistance to his regime, essentially giving carte blanche to his military to commit acts of genocide against the Kurdish people. This included the use of chemical weapons against the Kurdish population and is estimated to have killed tens of thousands people as a result.

Go To Page: 1 2


The copyright of the article Double Standards in Middle East Politics is owned by . Permission to republish Double Standards in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.

Post this Article to facebook Add this Article to del.icio.us! Digg this Article furl this Article Add this Article to Reddit Add this Article to Technorati Add this Article to Newsvine Add this Article to Windows Live Add this Article to Yahoo Add this Article to StumbleUpon Add this Article to BlinkLists Add this Article to Spurl Add this Article to Google Add this Article to Ask Add this Article to Squidoo


Here's the follow-up discussion on this article: View all related messages

5.   Apr 21, 1997 8:12 PM
An Article of Interest and commentary in [ ]


Report: Israel-S. Africa Nuke Link

Sunday, April 20, 1997 10:07 pm EDT


JERUSALEM (AP) -- Israel helped South Africa develop nuclear weapon ...


-- posted by Rafehh


4.   Apr 21, 1997 7:43 PM
An error in previous posting (reposted)

Again Mr. Siegel, the media does not single out Israel. Indeed, Israel has been coddled for a very long time by the media. For a very long time, the media an ...


-- posted by Rafehh


3.   Apr 21, 1997 10:39 AM

Again Mr. Siegel, the media does not single out Israel. Indeed, Israel has been coddled for a very long time by the media. For a very long time, the media and the North American establishment ignore ...

-- posted by Rafehh


2.   Apr 18, 1997 6:59 PM
I will try to confine my discussion to the Middle East since discussing the Holocaust or South Africa, a country that I have not studied in great detail and can't comment on its current or previous po ...

-- posted by Lawhawk


1.   Apr 18, 1997 2:45 PM
Mr. Siegel, your article outraged me. I find it outrageous when people attempt to justify massive human right violation and try to minimize it by implicating that (1) this is the language they underst ...

-- posted by Rafehh





For a complete listing of article comments, questions, and other discussions related to lawhawk's Middle East Politics topic, please visit the Discussions page.