Book Review: Immanuel! God Is Still with Us!

In Immanuel! God Is Still With Us! John Hoh sets out his Christian beliefs in the hope that others will find some comfort in them. From a British perspective, these views appear somewhat extreme - outright rejection of evolution, privileging of the existing text of the bible (although the translation and editing process chosen do not appear to be credited or discussed) and the equation of abortion with casual murder - however, these forms of belief seem to be more common in the USA. In any case, the author is writing for a like-minded author and does not feel the need to provide substantial supporting arguments for his views.

The book is divided into chapters such as "Immanuel in the Creation of Each Person," "Immanuel in the Preservation of the World" and "Immanuel Remains with Us - Until the End of Time." Each makes liberal use of translations of biblical texts, mixed with additional material such as extracts from St Augustine and some of the author's own memories of his catechism class. With such a wide range of sources from which to pick, of course, it is possible to put together an argument for pretty well any moral position. Those whose beliefs are similar to John Hoh's will presumably find this to be reassuring and even comforting. Those whose beliefs differ might prefer to reserve their opinions or to take up the cudgels in a suitable forum.

The beginning of the book adopts a creationist position and aims to make the argument that God is with all of us all of the time, pays attention to the universe, and answers various prayers and petitions. These will be issues of interest to those holding such beliefs and, given the heat with which matters of dogma and ideology are usually discussed, many will wish to become involved in such discussions. Anyone wishing to learn more of John Hoh's beliefs will do well to read this, which highlights his world view well. I would certainly welcome hearing alternative viewpoints from others who would take more from the book.

John Walsh, Shinawatra International University, August 2004

This book is available through Amazon.com through Suite 101's Co-op Marketplace.

Go To Page: 1

Articles in this Topic    Discussions in this Topic