Mobile Phones: Digital vs. Analog


© Asif Iqbal
Articles in this Topic    Discussions in this Topic

In my previous article I mentioned that GSM phones were the best option for every cellular user. Let us first compare digital technology with analog and later we will compare GSM technology with other digital as well as analog technologies and see which is actually the best.

More and more wireless service providers are shifting from analog to digital. Even though analog technology was the foundation of many of today's large networks, newer more advanced digital networks are fast replacing it. Let us look at the reason behind this evolution/revolution. Many wireless service providers "upgrading" to digital networks citing the benefits that digital networks offer. Some of these advantages are better quality of service, more security and privacy for customers, and ability to support next-generation services. Next-generation services, which are the buzzword nowadays, include wireless Internet applications, voice/video conferencing etc.

Another reason is that a digital channel can cover a lot more transmissions than an analog channel, meaning an operator can fit more information into each transmission. The underlying implication is more return on investment. Digital networks enable service providers to give to their customers a whole compliment of additional services which include call waiting, voice mail, text messages, answering machines etc.

Digital networks do offer better sound quality but that comes with its limitations (mentioned later in the article). As far as security is concerned digital networks are a step ahead. Since digital networks scramble transmissions into small burst there is less danger of scanning and cloning. Cloning can be termed as the cellular version of hacking. Cloning can be very disruptive/destructive if the account information falls into the wrong hands. Another thing is that digital transmissions consumer less battery power giving not only longer standby and talk times but also smaller, sleek looking battery packs and ultimately aesthetically better phones.

On the other hand we have analog networks. Other than the obvious advantages of digital networks mentioned above there are some features in analog networks that can counter the digital benefits. Starting from the basics, analog is cheaper. It is cheaper for the wireless service provider to install the systems and subsequently it is cheaper for the consumer to use it. Secondly digital mobile sets, because of their sleek looks and cutting edge technology, are expensive as compared to the analogs.

Roaming has always been a problem in the digital world as the industry standard has yet to become widespread. But as GSM has now become the worldwide standard, this problem has lost its teeth. One major advantage with analog is that they have already established huge networks. This gives greater accessibility to the customer, which is a great comparative advantage that the analogs have over digital networks.

Go To Page: 1 2 3


Post this Article to facebook Add this Article to del.icio.us! Digg this Article furl this Article Add this Article to Reddit Add this Article to Technorati Add this Article to Newsvine Add this Article to Windows Live Add this Article to Yahoo Add this Article to StumbleUpon Add this Article to BlinkLists Add this Article to Spurl Add this Article to Google Add this Article to Ask Add this Article to Squidoo