The Daughters of Zion: An Analysis of Isaiah Part 3


© Michelle Powell-Smith
Articles in this Topic    Discussions in this Topic

This paper will focus specifically on Isaiah 3:16-4:1. This passage begins by criticizing the "daughters of Zion" for their elaborate dress and vanity. Their crime, however, goes beyond mere vanity, for female vanity is intrinsically linked to female sexuality. It goes on to discuss their punishment. The women are stripped of not only their finery but also their beauty. They are reduced to begging for the protection of a man, even absolving him of basic responsibility. In analyzing this text, we must consider several major points: first, who are the "daughters of Zion"; second, why is their crime of vanity such a great one, worthy of such severe punishment?

In order to analyze this passage, we must first understand who the "daughters of Zion" are in relation to their society. The "daughters of Zion" are the women of Jerusalem; however, they are more specifically the wealthy women of Jerusalem. This is indicated both by their elaborate dress and also by the preceding verse, 3:14-15, which criticizes the oppression of the poor. While their wealth is evident, we can make no assumptions beyond this. These women are not only wealthy, but more specifically, haughty. Similar charges are leveled against wealthy women in Amos 4:1-3. These women, called the "cows of Bashan," are, in Amos' mind, responsible for the unscrupulous behavior of their husbands. There is also, as there is throughout these prophetic condemnations of women, an allusion to their sexuality in the use of the term "cows". They clearly flaunt their wealth, beauty and sexuality.

These women, the "daughters of Zion" are, in large part, responsible for the punishment Yahweh has leveled against the people of Jerusalem. The fault of these unfortunate women is most evident in Isaiah 4:4, when Yahweh purges the city of the "filth of the daughters of Zion."

The upper class women of Jerusalem are condemned for a crime other than their haughtiness, and it is a crime that defies the simplest explanations. The women are condemned for their vanity. While vanity appears a self-explanatory crime, it goes far beyond a simple interest in appearances, even an interest that goes beyond what is acceptable. A woman's value in the marketplace of marriage was based on several factors, including the wealth and status that she might bring her husband, but also on her sexual desirability. However, more important than her beauty, was her fidelity and behavior. According to Proverbs 31:10-31, a good wife will be hard working, diligent, wise and kind. She will be modest and fear the Lord. It is clear that the daughters of Zion do not fit this depiction of a good wife. Therefore, their vanity not only defied the traditional definition of a good wife, but also indicated that they were concerning themselves with matters other than the running of their household. Their sexuality is openly displayed to all, just as a prostitute displays her sexuality. Sexuality was, in and of itself, a good thing, but only when constrained by the bonds of propriety, such as marriage. Beauty was a desirable quality in a wife; however, it was not meant to be shared with others. These women sought, by increasing their desirability, to increase their power, finding power in and through their sexuality. The prophets, including Isaiah, played upon stereotypical fears of women's sexuality and power in passages like this one. The women are judged not for their vanity, but rather because their attitude destroys order within their society.

Go To Page: 1 2


Post this Article to facebook Add this Article to del.icio.us! Digg this Article furl this Article Add this Article to Reddit Add this Article to Technorati Add this Article to Newsvine Add this Article to Windows Live Add this Article to Yahoo Add this Article to StumbleUpon Add this Article to BlinkLists Add this Article to Spurl Add this Article to Google Add this Article to Ask Add this Article to Squidoo